Improving Hybrid Models for Precipitation Forecasting by Combining Nonlinear Machine Learning Methods

Laleh Parviz, Kabir Rasouli, Ali Torabi Haghighi

Water Resources Management · 26 May 2023

In one sentence. Ensembles combining GEP, SVR and GMDH improve hybrid precipitation forecasts at two Iranian stations, with MSE reduced by 67% at Rasht.

Abstract

Abstract Precipitation forecast is key for water resources management in semi-arid climates. The traditional hybrid models simulate linear and nonlinear components of precipitation series separately. But they do not still provide accurate forecasts. This research aims to improve hybrid models by using an ensemble of linear and nonlinear models. Preprocessing configurations and each of the Gene Expression Programming (GEP), Support Vector Regression (SVR), and Group Method of Data Handling (GMDH) models were used as in the traditional hybrid models. They were compared against the proposed hybrid models with a combination of all these three models. The performance of the hybrid models was improved by different methods. Two weather stations of Tabriz and Rasht in Iran with respectively annual and monthly time steps were selected to test the improved models. The results showed that Theil’s coefficient, which measures the inequality degree to which forecasts differ from observations, improved by 9% and 15% for SVR and GMDH relative to GEP for the Tabriz station. The applied error criteria indicated that the proposed hybrid models have a better representation of observations than the traditional hybrid models. Mean square error decreased by 67% and Nash Sutcliffe increased by 5% in the Rasht station when we combined the three machine learning models using genetic algorithm instead of SVR. Generally, the representation of the nonlinear models within the improved hybrid models showed better performance than the traditional hybrid models. The improved models have implications for modeling highly nonlinear systems using the full advantages of machine learning methods.

Labels

Labels and summary are generated by Claude and reviewed weekly. Wrong? Edit this entry.